return Home

Platforms and publishers: No sign of retreat

Despite publishers' disillusionment with low financial returns, there is no sign of them retreating from publishing material directly onto Facebook, Snapchat, Instagram and other distribution platforms.

This story was originally published by the Columbia Journalism Review (CJR). See the article here. The author, Pete Brown, is senior research fellow at the Tow Center for Digital Journalism, and runs the Content Analysis Hub for the Publishers and Platforms project.

Anxiety and uncertainty abound around the future of journalism. The initial promises from social media platforms of revenue for publishers are yet to materialise. Even as traffic rises, monetisation remains a work in progress. Some publishers and industry watchers have started to question the conventional wisdom pushing the pursuit of scale.

In looking more closely at the relationship between platforms and publishers, it’s impossible to escape the conclusion that platforms are the dominant partner. Mark Zuckerberg’s manifesto last week reminded us that social platforms like Facebook need the words produced by newsrooms to feed its billions of users and generate digital advertising revenue. Publishers rely on social media to exponentially increase the visibility of their work, and to bring in ad dollars via revenue-sharing models that are, slowly, being established.

Research conducted by the Tow Center for Digital Journalism shows publishers wading deeper into the Wild West of social media. During election week alone, the 14 publishers CJR studied made a total of 12,120 posts designed to sit natively on platforms, rather than drive traffic back to their own websites—an average of 866 per publisher.

CJR began tracking publishers’ activity on social platforms nine months ago as part of their ongoing Platforms and Publishers project. Their first week-long study in April 2016 covered nine publishers across 12 social platforms: The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, The Huffington Post, CNN, The Washington Post, Fox News, Vox, Vice News, and BuzzFeed . CJR have repeated this data collection quarterly, and expanded the research to include four additional platforms and five more publishers, including three regional publishers: the Los Angeles Times, Chicago Tribune, New York Daily News, Buzzfeed News, and Vice.

In April 2016, here’s how nine diverse journalism companies were posting across 21 different platforms:

CJR Apr 2016 ()

By February 2017, here’s how this landscape shifted:

CJR Feb 2017 ()

There is no singular trend in the data we collected. Publishers are still experimenting with how best to reach, retain, and monetise their audiences. Meanwhile, the platform landscape is constantly changing: The tech companies behind the social platforms are continually competing to outdo (or replicate) their rivals’ latest innovations as they wage their own battles to keep publishers not just on but in their platforms.

For the full story, including 10 key takeaways (and charts) from the three phases of data collection on platforms and publishers, click here.

More like this

[Long read] Time to rethink the (often maligned) comment section?

Three industry insiders on journalism in 2017

Social media 'leaves publishers in the dust, connecting people around stories'

  • What to expect as Hearst Magazines' new Airbnbmag hits the streets Chief content officer Joanna Coles discusses the premiere edition of Airbnbmag, its celebration of global community and the future of travel. 22nd May 2017 MagWorld
  • Eight lessons from Cosmopolitan on publishing to Snapchat Discover One of the lessons for Cosmopolitan following the brand’s wildly successful launch on Snapchat Discover just short of 2.5 years ago was that “you have to dig beyond analytics to find out what [users] are saying about your editions and what they really care about”. 22nd May 2017 MagWorld
  • Inside The Business of Fashion In the space of only a decade, The Business of Fashion has grown from a blog to multi-channel business servicing a global professional community in the millions through a website, newsletters, social media, print magazine and membership programme, with clear, diversified revenue model and each stream contributing meaningfully to the overall top line. 23rd May 2017 MagWorld
  • The Immediate Media Co story: from starting up to being acquired by Burda Earlier this month at the PPA Festival, Barry Mcllheney of the UK Publishers Association sat down with Immediate Media Co’s CEO, Tom Bureau, who talked about the journey from starting Immediate to being acquired by German-based publisher, Hubert Burda.  24th May 2017 MagWorld
  • Transitioning to digital when print still pays the bills For most publishers, transitioning from print to digital is the essential change. But when print magazines remain the most profitable part of your business, it can be important to balance evolution rationally in order not to lose the print cash cow. Here, we talk to Danish company, Bonnier Publications, about walking that very path. 25th May 2017 MagWorld
Go to Full Site